I finally got around to reading Rob Bell’s book, Love Wins: A Book About Heaven, Hell, and the Fate of Every Person Who Ever Lived
. This book has been out for a good while now, but I am slow sometimes to actually read the books I get. This is not going to be a comprehensive review. I would like to just make a few comments about Rob Bell, and what I came away with.
First, as I read the book, the thing that stood out is that Rob Bell doesn’t like the orthodox views of Christianity. It is clear that the Bible’s text is not to be taken for what it literally says. His interpretations are not what anyone who just picks up a Bible and begins to read it would come away with.
Second, as I read it was obvious that Rob wasn’t interested in actually engaging Bible scholars in the actual doctrine of Heaven or Hell. What it seems he was doing was trying to discredit the literal view of Hell with a view that would be popular to a society that rejects the Bible and its message. When you read Rob Bell, he explains things as if his view is the only view that makes sense, without actually stating that it is right. He gives a lot of opinion, talks a lot about culture, goes to the Greek and Hebrew, and when it is convenient for his argument talks about accepted Biblical views of God. To a person who has little Bible training, he seems to know what he is talking about, and his message is acceptable and not offensive.
So some things I learned from Bell.
What does Bell actually teach about Hell?
- It’s a garbage dump, and when asked if he believes in Hell, he answers “yes, I believe my garbage goes somewhere.”
- It isn’t punishment but correction.
- It is here and now in the suffering and evil that people encounter.
- It is a state of being unhappy in God’s kingdom.
- It may be in the after life.
- It isn’t forever.
What does Bell teach about Heaven?
- Heaven is here now.
- Everybody eventually gets there.
- In Heaven everyone will be good and happy, except those who are bad, and they will be in Hell, because Heaven isn’t fun if you aren’t good, so the bad will be unhappy until they learn to be good, then they too will finally be in Heaven.
Bell is a universalist. He redefines Hell so that it is something that is easier to accept. In many ways, I wish Bell was right. I wish Hell was not an everlasting place of punishment. But it is. Bell tries to convince us that the word for “eternal” should be translated as “age.” However, this isn’t true. Check almost every Bible translation and you will see that the translators used the word “everlasting” or “eternal.” Bell wants us to think that all these translators made a mistake but that he has it right. The translators are right. Hell is a place of everlasting punishment. Bell just throws out the Greek word and claims it should be translated “age” but the word is “aionion” It is an adjective, and it is the same word used to describe “everlasting life.” In the same verse sometimes, such as in Matthew 25. So if everlasting punishment is not what is meant, neither is everlasting life. Bell, never actually says he believes that.
Bell makes the argument that a God who would punish people forever is not a God anyone would want to believe in. He says that isn’t love. What Bell does here is define God and Love by his own standards. Yet later in the book, Bell seems to state that he believes God is sovereign. God is sovereign to Bell when he wants to show that God would not let anybody be punished forever, because a sovereign God would never fail to do what He wants, and that He would be failing if anyone were to actually perish. Bell explains his view that God doesn’t want anyone to perish or miss everlasting life. (But Bell claims that their is no everlasting punishment.) But, Bell doesn’t believe God is sovereign in His choice to determine what love is, or whether He can be good and still punish the wicked.
Bell, speaks little about the reason for eternal punishment. He speaks little about sin. He speaks little about God’s holiness. Bell seems to not understand why Christ actually died on the cross. Bell doesn’t believe someone must actually believe on Christ to receive eternal life, but he mentions that everyone would be saved because of Christ. The problem is that if Bell’s other views are right, Christ didn’t need to die to begin with.
There is just so much wrong with Bell’s views. To me, it seems Bell doesn’t know what he believes. He doesn’t come right out and say he is right. He doesn’t come right out and say everyone else is wrong. But, he does make it clear that he has chosen to live, and teach as if Hell is not something that anyone should be worried about.
I would not recommend any young believer read this book. I would not recommend any unbeliever read this book. I would however, recommend reading Francis Chan’s book Erasing Hell: What God said about eternity, and the things we made up
, which I have just started. Also, believe what the Bible says. You don’t have to ask Rob Bell what the Scriptures mean. It is pretty clear on the doctrine of Hell, sin, and the need for Christ.
John 14:6 Jesus said to him, “I am the way, and the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.